Unnecessary Surgery, Insurance Fraud, and You


November 5, 2015 / Medical Malpractice

Have you had any surgeries in the past few years? Think back, especially if it involved your heart or circulatory system. Perhaps you had spinal fusion or a joint replacement done. Did you have any surgery done because the doctor told you that you needed it?

Often we have surgery because the doctor tells us that surgery is the only option. Few of us have the medical knowledge to ask the right questions regarding alternatives. We do what the doctor tells us to do, especially if death is mentioned.

The lure of easy insurance money, especially when it is from Medicare or Medicaid, can play a part in a surgical recommendation if the doctor is not ethical. Here in Indiana, a group of cardiologists and a hospital, Cardiology Associates of Northwest Indiana and Munster Community Hospital, are being sued for unnecessary surgeries.

Too Many Procedures, So Much Money

About a year ago, dozens of people began suing the groups listed above, alleging unnecessary procedures. In some cases, wrongful death arising from those procedures is alleged. Some say that the investigation has revealed that 75 percent of heart procedures were performed unnecessarily.

One patient, Steve Mayerak, whose second opinions revealed that his procedures and surgeries were unnecessary, commented, “I’ve had 10 angiograms, [a] defibrillator and pacemakers which I since found out I didn’t need.”

The motive for unnecessary surgery, of course, is money. A defibrillator procedure brings in about as much revenue as the cost of a medium-sized car, and is one of the most lucrative procedures a hospital can do. The three doctors involved in the suit are the top three cardiologists in Indiana when it comes to payments they get from Medicare. One of them is twentieth in the entire U.S., based on the amount of Medicare money ending up in his accounts.

To give you an idea of the numbers of medical procedures done annually in the U.S., it’s around 51.4 million in total for all procedures. Here are the annual numbers for some of the most common cardiac procedures:

  • Arteriography and angiocardiography: 2.4 million
  • Cardiac catheterizations: 1.0 million
  • Balloon angioplasty of coronary artery/coronary atherectomy: 500,000
  • Insertion of coronary artery stent: 454,000
  • Coronary artery bypass graft: 395,000.

We are thankful that the overwhelming majority of doctors are honest, but, because these surgeries are so commonly done, there’s always a chance that someone dishonest will be tempted to take advantage of that and “cash in.”

Surgeries That Might Not Be Needed

Unneeded surgeries carry risks beyond the financial losses; it’s not just about the money. Anesthesia has known dangers up to and including death, especially for folks over 65. Post-operative infections are also a risk. Pain, and decreased future mobility and capacity, are also likely hazards.

Some of the most frequent unnecessary medical procedures are:

  • Cardiac stents
  • Pacemakers
  • Cardiac catheterization
  • Back surgery, including spinal fusion
  • Knee and other joint replacements
  • Hysterectomy
  • Caesarean section (C-section).

It is speculated that unnecessary surgeries can amount to as many as 20 percent in some medical specialties. In the past 10 years, over 1,000 doctors have paid to settle or close surgical malpractice claims involving charges of unnecessary or inappropriate procedures.

By definition, unnecessary surgeries or procedures constitute medical malpractice.

When others breach their duty, we keep ours.

Our investigative team goes to work immediately to uncover the who,’ ‘what,’ ‘when,’ ‘where,’ ‘why’ and ‘how’ of medical injuries caused by malpractice. We are committed to bringing together the most qualified experts available (irrespective of cost) to uncover what happened. Your experts will come from around the world if necessary. Medical malpractice claims can be complex. Therefore, it is the proficiency of your experts that is crucial in both the investigation and litigation phases of your claim.

Mike Stephenson is a Martindale-Hubbell AV-rated attorney, the highest possible attorney peer rating. When you call Mike, you can have complete confidence that you are talking with an Indiana medical malpractice lawyer with over 30 years’ experience offering compassionate and successful representation for his clients. What is your next step toward justice? Contact the trusted advisors and proven advocates, Stephenson Rife, today using our contact form, or call 1-317-825-5200.

Attorney Mike Stephenson

Attorney Mike StephensonMike Stephenson has 40 years of experience and is a trusted advisor to many individuals and companies. His current practice is dominated by civil litigation in state and federal courts. He focuses much of his time on handling catastrophic injuries caused by all types of accidents, including motor vehicle, trucking, workplace injuries, product liability, and fire, just to name a few. He also works extensively in construction accidents. [ Attorney Bio ]

Table of Contents

Featured Posts

  • What to Do if Your Motorcycle Is Hit by a Car from BehindWhat to Do if Your Motorcycle Is Hit by a Car from Behind
    In Vehicle Accidents
    The average motorcycle weighs just 700 pounds, and when one collides with a much heavier truck or car, the consequences can be severe. Motorcycle accidents are often deadly. You may be asking what to do if your motorcycle is hit by a car from behind. Are there certain steps you should take to ensure your immediate safety? Let’s take a closer look at motorcycle crashes. There were 8,596,314 motorcycles registered in the U.S. in 2019, […]
  • Can I Sue for a Concussion?Can I Sue for a Concussion?
    In Personal Injury
    You’ve received a blow to the head that resulted in an injury and left you with medical bills you didn’t expect to deal with. Now you’re asking, “Can I sue for a concussion?” The answer to the question is yes, you can sue for damages provided you can show proof of injury and that the blow to your head was the result of negligence, even if the concussion was mild. A concussion is caused by a blow to the […]
  • How Often Do Car Accident Cases Go to CourtHow Often Do Car Accident Cases Go to Court?
    In Car Accidents
    About every 10 seconds someone is injured in a motor vehicle accident in the United States, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). This means a lot of motorists are getting hurt every day. While there are no exact figures available, the majority of car accident lawsuits – an estimated 95% — are settled before trial. So, if you’re asking how often do car accident cases go to court, the answer is […]

Archives