Truck Accident Multimillion-Dollar Settlement.

"M.A.," a 30-year-old man, was driving to work in New Mexico. Suddenly a commercial truck veered across the center line and struck his vehicle head on. M.A. died at the scene. The McNeely Stephenson firm was hired shortly after the crash to represent the family of the deceased.

our client results

Insurance Bad Faith Claims Made in Indianapolis

How our Indiana attorneys can help…Not only can a personal injury lawyer help by explaining the coverage of the insurance policy in terms that you can easily understand, he or she will act as a buffer between you and the adjuster assigned to your claim. If a settlement offer is made, your attorney will be able to advise you whether it is reasonable or may suggest a counter-offer.

Indiana Car Insurance Bad Faith

Insurance companies are required to deal with claimants in good faith. They must honor their contract with the insured and pay legitimate claims. That’s true whether the claim is being made as a result of a motor vehicle accident, a bicycle accident, a house fire, or an occupational injury. If they don’t, they may be held to account in a bad faith civil suit.

Read more below about insurance companies and bad faith claims handling. If you feel that an insurance company has been dealing with you unfairly, call Mike Stephenson, Indianapolis bad faith lawyer, at 317-825-5200 for a free initial consultation and evaluation of your potential claim against the company. When others breach their duty, we keep ours.

Actions that could be evidence of bad faith

Not every denial of a claim or a disappointing offer is evidence of bad faith. Under Indiana law, Code § 27-4-1-4.5, these are some of the claim settlement practices declared to be unfair:

(1) Misrepresenting pertinent facts or provisions of the insurance policy provisions which relate to the accident; for example, telling the claimant that the policy doesn’t cover a certain type of loss when it actually does.

(2) Failing to acknowledge and act “reasonably promptly” when notified of a claim. While this is open to interpretation, most companies expect their employees to acknowledge a claim within 14 days.

(3) Failing to either affirm or deny coverage of claims within a reasonable time after proof of loss statements have been completed.

(4) Refusing to pay claims without conducting a reasonable investigation based upon all available information; for example, denying payment for a car wreck without obtaining a copy of the police report which could implicate their insured.

(5) Not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair, and equitable settlements of claims in which liability has become reasonably clear.

(6) Attempting to settle a claim for less than the amount to which a reasonable person would have believed he was entitled or attempting to substantially diminish a claim and compelling the insured to initiate litigation.

Disagreeable, but not Unfair

Dealing with an insurance company after an accident is not always a pleasant task. Their questions may make you feel defensive; they may want to take a recorded statement from you or require you to fill out papers; the insurance adjuster may not be very understanding of your problems . . . after all, their main focus is protecting their company’s bottom line.

These are some of the realities of having an accident claim that may be disagreeable but are not considered evidence of bad faith:

  • The insurance company may offer less than you think you deserve. Just because you and the adjuster have a difference of opinion about how much your claim is worth, this doesn’t necessarily mean the company is acting in bad faith. If they refuse to give you any reasons for their evaluation or seem to be simply bullying you into taking them to court, contact a bad faith lawyer. You can use our online contact form.
  • You may be required to give an Examination Under Oath (EUO) – and even more than one. Virtually all property and casualty policies (those that cover your home, auto, business, or contents) give the insurance company the option of investigating your claim by means of an EUO. Because your answers to the questions can be used to deny your claim, you should seek counsel from an experienced attorney to help you with this.
  • You may disagree with an insurer’s denial of your claim. But unless the denial was made with “dishonest purpose, moral obliquity, furtive design, or ill will,” the company will not be found to have acted in bad faith.

How an Attorney Can Help

Not only can a personal injury lawyer help by explaining the coverage of the insurance policy in terms that you can easily understand, he or she will act as a buffer between you and the adjuster assigned to your claim. If a settlement offer is made, your attorney will be able to advise you whether it is reasonable or may suggest a counter-offer.

More than that, studies have shown that claimants who have hired attorneys wind up getting significantly more than those who go it alone. The Insurance Research Council found that, on average, insurance payouts are 3.5 times higher for clients who have legal counsel.

Having a lawyer representing you in your claim against an insurance company may discourage any effort on their part to unreasonably delay or deny what you are due. If they do act in bad faith and there is clear and convincing evidence that they acted with malice, fraud, gross negligence or oppressiveness, you may be able to recover punitive damages in excess of the policy’s limits.

real-life cases

We have won numerous multi-million dollar cases for our clients.

See examples of how we helped clients whose lives were turned upside down by reckless or negligent acts of others. We took on negligent county officials when D.H. flew over his handlebars while riding on a bridge left in disrepair for years. We brought justice to the family of of J.M. and his wife after a defective tire ended their lives. We held a drunk driver and those who served him alcohol accountable when he seriously injured B.K., who also lost three family members in a crash.

Read more examples of how we get justice and compensation for our clients.


Let Our Resources Back You Up

Pursuing a bad faith claim against an insurance company is a complex undertaking. You will need an attorney who understands the case law on bad faith claims handling and one who has the resources to take on a large company with its own legal department and plenty of assets to fight your claim.

At McNeely Stephenson, we have been successfully litigating Indiana personal injury cases since 1982, putting our resources to work for those who have been denied fair dealing and just compensation. Call us as soon as you have been injured in a car, truck or bicycle crash, in a workplace accident, or as a result of a medical mistake, so we can help you obtain the compensation you are entitled to. Dial 317-825-5200.

Personal Injury Lawyer
July 12, 2019 / Truck Accidents
How Many Truck Accidents Happen Annually?

Big rigs are an essential component of the U.S. economy, transporting goods and parts that consumers need. The trucking industry is regulated by a government agency called the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMSCA), whose job it is to prevent injuries and accidents through safety regulations, technological advancements, and other measures. Carriers and individual drivers are required by law to adhere to FMSCA regulations. When the...


Mike Stephenson is a Super Lawyer in Indiana along with many of his peers at McNeely Stephenson. This is one of the highest honors an attorney can achieve

Indianapolis Law Firm


The AV Preeminent Rating from Martindale Hubbell is the HIGHEST RATING and considered a significant accomplishment. It is a peer-reviewed process reflecting that other attorneys rank Mike Stephenson at the highest possible level of professional excellence.

Indianapolis Law Firm


Attorney Mike Stephenson is a proud member of The Litigation Counsel of America’s Honorary Society. A close-knit, peer-selected, and aggressively diverse honorary society of 3,500 of the “best trial lawyers” in the country. Less than one-half of one percent of American lawyers, vigorously vetted for skills, expertise, and service; an invitation-only collegial network.

Indianapolis Law Firm


The American Board of Trial Advocates is an invitation-only organization for attorneys of “high personal character and honorable reputation.” ABOTA works for the preservation of the civil jury trial, “Justice by the People,” and supports the right of a jury trial.

Indianapolis Law Firm


The National Trial Lawyers: Top 100 is an invitation-only organization composed of the premier trial lawyers. Membership is extended only to the select few of the most qualified attorneys. Indiana attorney Mike Stephenson is proud to be included in this national organization of top trial lawyers.

Indianapolis Law Firm


Our attorneys are proven advocates and trial attorneys. They have served as lead trial counsel in more than 100 civil jury trials, and have handled litigation in 18 states

Indianapolis Law Firm